Most organizations acknowledge that price, quality and service are key success components.
Most will even go so far as to say customer service is the single most important
element in capturing the loyal and consistent patronage of customers. But very,
very few organizations will ever admit that peak organizational performance is rooted
in staff empowerment.
Empowerment requires both responsibility and authority. It not only allows, but
encourages everyone to be responsible. And, empowerment also puts trust in the staff’s
ability to make decisions, to take action, and do whatever needs to get done in
order to satisfy the customer. Unfortunately, most managers are simply afraid to
allow staff members to go the extra mile. The result is performance that always
falls short.
How many times have we all (personally and professionally) experienced being on
the receiving end of a staff hand-cuffed to the ball and chain of management? All we need is recall our experiences at what were formerly “fast food” hamburger chains.
Today to call them “fast food” is an oxymoron: What they really are, is a “slow
drive –thru to wait to see if our order is correct” outlet.
Then, there are our local movie theatres. We stand in line waiting for the manager
to allow the young cashier to stop the paper pushing long enough to sell us a ticket
so that we can go in to spend even more of our money on popcorn and drinks.
And, how many times have we all been at a hotel that offers a continental breakfast
only to find there are no cups for coffee? Worse yet, the clerk doesn’t have time
or the key to get more cups out of the locked cupboard?
And while not wanting to offend the healthcare community for similar acts, here’s
a brief list of what everyone (perhaps including you) has experienced in either
a hospital of doctor’s office or both:
- “Sorry, Mr. Brown, I can’t treat you until my boss gives the okay.”
- “If you can come back after lunch, I‘m sure I can get the duplicate x-ray that you
need for your surgery tomorrow morning.”
- “The requisition doesn’t specify which leg is to be x-rayed”
- I know your appointment was at 9:00 a.m., but it’s only 11:30 and I’m sure you’ll
be next.”
- “I realize your child has a temperature of 103, but there’s nothing I can do about
the air conditioning set at 68 degrees.”
The problem is organizations don’t trust their staff. Perhaps the even more deeply
rooted problem is that managers don’t trust themselves. You see, on the one hand,
we hire our staff members because they prove their ability through background and
personal interview. We hire them because we are satisfied and even encouraged they
can bring dimension to our organizations. There’s just one thing. We really don’t
want their dimension: We want them to be under our management thumb like everyone
else on the staff. So we socialize them to be like everyone else… a kind of Stepford
Wives surrealism.
Many employers say they have empowered employees, but few actually do. Why? Because
they don’t understand what real empowerment is. Too many managers think empowerment
is giving employees the “okay” to make a decision to take care of the customer…
as long as the action they take follows the rules, policies, and procedures of the
organization, which means there actually is no empowerment.
An empowered staff member has the “real authority” to do whatever is necessary to
immediately take care of a customer… to that customer’s satisfaction… not to the
company’s satisfaction. (This is the distinction between serving the organization
and serving the goal of the organization.) We cannot tie the employees’ hands with
cumbersome policies and procedures and expect them to provide exceptional service.
True empowerment means employees can modify, refine, sometimes even break the rules
to serve the customer. Management must recognize and remember: If the customer doesn’t
win, it’s the company that loses.
Many managers fear empowerment because they think it will diminish or eliminate their roles. Granted, they will have less “control” with empowered staffs, but that
doesn’t mean management is out of a job or even that the environment will get out
of order. It simply means managers will have to figure out whether it’s peak performance
they want or control by organizational grip-lock. The former is in line with why
managers got into management in the first place.
Disney World is the epitome of customer service and empowerment is like a religion
there. Employees are thoroughly trained and then told they have the responsibility
and authority to do whatever is necessary to solve problems on the spot in order
to make customers happy. The Disney philosophy is reflected in this statement: “Management
must not only support the front line, but must trust it as well. After all, these
are the persons we hired.” In fact, management interference is discouraged at Disney
World.
There are limits to empowerment, however. For example, empowerment doesn’t mean
that prices can be indiscriminately slashed to retain a customer. What it does mean
is that employees can take the initiative in solving customers problems so that
they will continue to do business with the oganisation. Front line employees must
have the authority to respond to the needs and problems of individual customers
with speed and courtesy. An example of exceptional customer service and empowerment
is L.L. Bean, Inc. One of its employees actually drove 500 miles from Maine to New York to deliver a canoe to a customer who was leaving on a trip the next day.
One of my friends checked into a hotel late one night and asked an employee if room
service was still available. It wasn’t. However, the employee offered to go into
the hotel kitchen and get the guest something to eat. That employee empowered himself.
He was sincerely concerned about the guest’s comfort and made the extra effort to
see that the guest did not go to bed hungry. I call this “breakaway service.” It
is the best of service: An employee going above and beyond the call of duty to ensure
that a customer is satisfied.
Exceptional service is putting the customer first, being responsive to a customer’s
needs, and being resourceful in meeting those needs. A Federal Express employee
was recognized for his resourcefulness when his truck broke down while he was making
deliveries. The employee called a tow truck then persuaded the driver (while towing
the Federal Express truck) to follow a route that coincided with his delivery route-and
to stop at each delivery site. That remarkable employee knows the value of service
and took it upon himself to deliver it.
The opportunity exists daily for staff to make a mark by doing whatever it takes
to deliver satisfaction to the customer. Empowering our colleagues to handle customer
complaints will not only maintain customer loyalty, it will engender it. But we
already know this. So, these insights are not in question. The real question is:
Do staff members trust management and management’s sense of self-confidence enough
to know they can push the envelope, draw
outside the lines, and do whatever is reasonably
necessary to satisfy customers?
The first step in empowering staff members is to invest in their orientation and
training. Most companies, however, think they should “train their people” for a
few minutes once every five years. Organisations who are serious about keeping customers
and maximizing profits, should be investing a minimum of 40 hours annually in orienting
each and every staff member in the skills of empowerment, customer service, quality,
performance, and the significance of extra mile efforts. Irony has it that most
employers spend more money on copy machine maintenance than they do on maintaining
the mindset of their staffs. Unfortunately, employees in those organizations break
down more often than their machines. Instead of those organizations investing in
Continuous Quality Improvement (CQI), they spend their money on “continuous employee
recruitment.”
Employers must realize that knowledgeable, courteous, helpful and empowered employees
bring in – and retain - customers. Thousands, even millions of dollars in advertising
and marketing will bring customers to the door; but poor service will turn them
away, keep them away and worst of all, drive them to competitors.
Empowerment is a powerful management instrument that guides organisations of all
sizes and configurations to new heights of performance. Its focus is on the individual
staff member’s right to perform independently, intellectually, and passionately.
And while the ultimate benefit is intended for customer satisfaction, everyone benefits.
The organization is applauded for peak performance. Staff members are lauded for
peak accomplishment. And empowerment is celebrated.
John Tschohl, founder and president of Service Quality Institute